What happens if you are sued and simply do not show up? A high-profile bankruptcy case involving former college football player Shilo Sanders offers a dramatic answer, and an important warning for individuals and business owners alike.
Most people do not want to be involved in a lawsuit. A complaint arrives, a business dispute escalates, a former partner makes a claim, or a customer, vendor, employee or creditor threatens legal action. The temptation may be to hope the problem goes away.
Usually, it does not.
The ongoing bankruptcy case involving Shilo Sanders, son of football coach Deion Sanders, is an extraordinary example of how failing to actively defend a lawsuit can have consequences that last for years.
Sanders was sued in Texas over an incident that occurred while he was in high school. He initially defended the lawsuit, but his attorneys withdrew in 2020 after reporting to the court that Sanders was unwilling or unable to continue funding the defense. Sanders did not have new counsel in place when the matter eventually went to trial in 2022, and he did not appear.
The court proceeded without him and ultimately entered a judgment of approximately $11.89 million against him.
Sanders later filed for Chapter 7 bankruptcy.
That is where this story becomes much more than celebrity news. It becomes a lesson about litigation, default judgments, business risk, and a dangerous misconception: if a lawsuit goes badly enough, bankruptcy will simply erase the problem.
Sometimes bankruptcy provides exactly the fresh start someone needs. But it is not an undo button.
A Lawsuit Does Not Stop Because You Ignore It
One of the most important things to understand about civil litigation is simple: the other side does not necessarily need your participation to keep moving forward.
In Ohio, Civil Rule 55 provides a process for obtaining a default judgment when a party fails to plead or otherwise defend a case. That means throwing a complaint in a drawer, failing to respond, missing important notices, or assuming a dispute will somehow resolve itself can be enormously costly.
A defendant who participates in the case has the opportunity to challenge allegations, present evidence, raise defenses, question witnesses, negotiate, pursue settlement, assert counterclaims when appropriate, and require the plaintiff to prove the case. Failing to defend yourself can mean giving up some of the very opportunities that might have changed the outcome.
Sanders’ situation is especially striking because he had previously participated in the litigation. He had attorneys, filed counterclaims and participated in a deposition before eventually proceeding without counsel. When the case later went to trial, he was not there to present his side.
The court heard the plaintiff’s evidence without him, and the result was an $11.89 million judgment.
Having a Defense Is Not the Same as Defending the Case
Sanders has maintained that he acted in self-defense in the underlying incident. That illustrates another important point.
A person may believe strongly that the facts are on their side, but having a defense and actually presenting that defense in court are two very different things.
Courts decide cases based on the legal process, the evidence properly before them, and the arguments made by the parties. A defense that is never properly raised may do very little good.
This applies far beyond personal injury lawsuits. A small-business owner may believe a vendor breached the contract first, that the amount being claimed is wrong, that a former employee’s allegations omit important facts, that a customer caused the problem, or that insurance should cover the dispute. There may be emails, contracts, invoices, photographs, witnesses or other evidence that tell a very different story.
Those facts may matter enormously, but the court cannot be expected to discover and present your side of the case for you.
For Business Owners, the Stakes Can Become Serious Quickly
Small-business litigation often begins with something that does not initially look catastrophic.
It may start with an invoice dispute, a disagreement over a contract, a partnership breakup, a lease issue, a customer complaint, a former employee, or a disagreement over who failed to perform an obligation.
Then a demand letter arrives. After that, perhaps a summons.
That is the moment to take the situation seriously.
At Godbey Law, we counsel businesses on contracts, liability, business disputes and other legal issues, and we represent clients when litigation becomes necessary. Good business representation is not only about winning lawsuits. It is also about identifying problems early enough to prevent them from becoming unnecessarily expensive.
There may also be insurance coverage that needs to be investigated promptly. Certain policies may require timely notice. Documents, emails and electronic records may need to be preserved. In some cases, there may be an opportunity to resolve a dispute before legal fees and potential exposure grow substantially.
The worst strategy is often doing nothing.
Can a Default Judgment Be Fixed Later?
Sometimes a party may be able to ask a court for relief from a default judgment, but no one should treat that as a backup strategy.
Ohio Civil Rule 60(B), for example, allows courts in certain circumstances to relieve a party from a final judgment for reasons such as mistake, inadvertence, surprise, excusable neglect, newly discovered evidence, fraud and other grounds. There are also timing requirements and legal standards that must be satisfied.
That does not mean someone can simply ignore a lawsuit and automatically reopen the case later.
Trying to set aside a judgment can become another legal fight, with no guarantee of success. It is generally far better to address the original lawsuit properly than to spend additional time and money trying to repair the consequences afterward.
Then Comes the Bankruptcy Question
The Sanders case adds another layer that makes it particularly relevant.
After collection efforts began on the $11.89 million judgment, Sanders filed for Chapter 7 bankruptcy. The judgment represents the overwhelming majority of the debt involved in his bankruptcy case.
Bankruptcy can be an extraordinarily valuable legal tool. Depending on the circumstances, it can stop collection activity, address overwhelming debt, and provide individuals and businesses with an opportunity to reorganize or obtain a financial fresh start.
Godbey Law represents clients in bankruptcy matters, including Chapter 7 and Chapter 13 cases, as well as matters involving personal and business debt.
But bankruptcy does not automatically eliminate every debt.
Federal bankruptcy law contains several exceptions to discharge, including certain debts arising from a willful and malicious injury by a debtor to another person or another person’s property.
That issue is now central to the Sanders bankruptcy case. The creditor is asking the bankruptcy court to determine that the $11.89 million judgment should not be discharged. Sanders continues to contend that the underlying incident involved self-defense.
The bankruptcy court has already ruled that the Texas judgment has binding effect on certain issues involving causation and damages, while other questions remain to be decided.
So, years after the original lawsuit began, the dispute is still being litigated. Only now, the question is whether an $11.89 million debt can survive bankruptcy.
Bankruptcy Is Powerful, But It Is Not a Substitute for Defending a Lawsuit
This distinction matters.
Bankruptcy may discharge many types of debt. It may stop garnishments and other collection activity. It may give someone facing an impossible financial situation the breathing room needed to start over.
But whether a particular judgment can be discharged depends on the nature of the debt, the facts behind it and the applicable law.
That is why the idea of ignoring a lawsuit now and dealing with it later through bankruptcy can be an extremely expensive gamble.
The better question is what options are available now.
Sometimes the answer is to fight the case. Sometimes it makes sense to negotiate. Sometimes insurance should be involved. Sometimes an early settlement is financially prudent. Sometimes the allegations are defensible. Sometimes bankruptcy is part of the solution.
And sometimes several of those strategies need to be considered together.
What Should You Do If You or Your Business Is Sued?
The first step is to take the matter seriously and act quickly.
Court deadlines matter. An attorney can review the allegations, determine what response may be required, identify potential defenses and evaluate whether insurance coverage, settlement discussions or other strategies should be considered.
It is also important to preserve contracts, emails, text messages, invoices, photographs, financial records and other information connected to the dispute. In a business case, those documents may ultimately become some of the most important evidence.
Finally, litigation decisions should be considered as both legal and financial decisions. The cost of defending the case, potential exposure, settlement opportunities, insurance coverage, collectability and even bankruptcy considerations may all affect the best strategy.
The $11.89 Million Lesson
The most important lesson from the Sanders case is not about football, celebrity or one family’s decisions.
It is that legal problems rarely become less expensive simply because they are ignored.
An unresolved claim can become a lawsuit. An undefended lawsuit can become a judgment. A judgment can become a collection problem. And a collection problem can become a bankruptcy case where the parties are still fighting years later over whether the debt can ever be eliminated.
The earlier you understand your options, the more options you are likely to have.
Facing a Lawsuit, Business Dispute or Serious Debt Problem?
Godbey Law LLC represents individuals and businesses throughout Greater Cincinnati, Southwestern Ohio and Northern Kentucky in civil litigation, small-business matters, business disputes and bankruptcy.
Whether you have just received a demand letter, have already been sued, are trying to resolve a business dispute, or are dealing with debt that has become unmanageable, speaking with an attorney early can help you understand your options before those options become more limited.
Call Godbey Law at 513-241-6650 or contact us online to discuss your situation.
This article is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Every case is different. Godbey Law LLC does not represent any of the parties discussed in the Shilo Sanders litigation or bankruptcy proceedings.